Skip to main content

0% commission: what the big portals really cost you

The per-cover fee is only the visible part. Whose guest a booking is, and what you can take with you, matter as much.

By TablestialPublished Updated

A man writing in a notebook at the bar of an empty restaurant, chairs turned up on the tables behind him
Contents

Every owner knows the line on the invoice. Many booking portals charge for each guest they seat, and at the end of the month the number is there in black and white. It is easy to argue about. Is it fair for a guest who found you on their own? Is it worth it in February? Those are real questions, but they are the smaller ones.

The larger question never appears on an invoice at all: whose guest the booking really is. Commission-free restaurant booking is the other way to run it, and what follows is what that changes.

How the per-cover fee actually behaves

A fee per cover sounds like a marketing cost: the network brings a guest, you pay for the introduction. That is easy to defend for a guest who found you there. It is harder to defend for a regular who already knew you and used the network because it was the quickest way. Whether the fee applies to that regular depends on your contract. OpenTable's UK plans page, for one, says its cover fee applies only to diners who find you on its website, app or affiliate network, and not to bookings made on your own website or by phone. So split your covers by source and read the contract: which covers carry the fee, and what counts when a regular returns through the network's app.

Where the fee is per cover, it grows with covers, so a full Friday costs more than a quiet Tuesday. In our view that is an odd way to price a tool whose job is to fill the room.

None of this makes portals villains. For a new place, or a restaurant that lives on visitors to the city, being listed where people browse can matter. The question is what you give up in return, and whether you still need to give it up once the room is known.

Whose guest is it?

A network booking is also a relationship between the diner and the network. The diner has an account there, and the network has its own terms with them. That is not a problem in itself, and it is not the same as the network keeping your data. OpenTable's support page says a guestbook export is a .csv file that includes marketing opt-in status, so a restaurant can take its guest list with it. Check what your own portal lets you export, and whether the export carries each guest's marketing consent.

What reaches you from any booking is a name, a time, a party size, sometimes a note. What makes a restaurant good at welcoming people is the history: which table they liked, that they came four times last winter and not once since the spring, that one of them does not eat shellfish. Over the years, that knowledge becomes one of the most valuable things a restaurant owns after its lease and its people. The question is where it lives, and whether you can use it.

This is a quiet cost, because nothing breaks and the room still fills. But if the history sits only in a system you cannot export from, each season you know your own guests a little less well than you could.

What changes when booking lives at home

Take the booking back to your own site and your own domain, and the arithmetic changes along with the relationship.

  • There is no fee per cover, so a regular costs nothing extra to seat and a busy night is simply a busy night.
  • The guest meets your restaurant first, in your style and your languages, with no rival listing one scroll away.
  • Every booking adds to your own guest book: visit history, notes, allergies, the table they chose.
  • You can write to your regulars directly, when they have agreed to hear from you, on the nights you need them.

That last point is where the economics turn. A restaurant that knows its regulars can write to them directly, as long as they agreed to hear from you: invite them back on a slow Wednesday, before the room sits half empty. It can reply to their reviews with care. It can greet them at the door by name, because the host read the note before service.

From reading to booking

See it on your own floor

Send a photo of your dining room and we bring your own tables to a 30-minute call.

Read commission-free booking →

Counting the whole cost

When you weigh a network against booking on your own site, put the visible fee on one side of the scale. Then add what the invoice leaves out. Which of the covers you pay for were already your regulars, if your contract counts them. Whether you can export your guest details with their marketing consent. What you cannot do with a guest list you do not hold. And the evenings you could have filled with people who already love the place, if you could reach them with their agreement.

Then ask what the portal still gives you that you cannot get anywhere else. For some restaurants the honest answer is discovery, and a listing may be worth keeping for that alone. For many established rooms, the answer turns out to be smaller than the fee.

We built Tablestial around that view. Bookings happen on the restaurant's own site, by choosing a real table in its own room, with 0% commission and no fee per cover. The guest book belongs to the restaurant. Birthday, anniversary and win-back offers go by email to guests who agreed to receive them, and you can send a campaign to the same guests. At the restaurant in our case study, all 68 seats are bookable on its own website, under its own name.

Whatever you choose, count the whole cost. The fee is only the part you can see.

Sources

  1. OpenTable pricing and plans (UK), OpenTable (checked )
  2. Export your Guestbook, OpenTable support (checked )

More from the blog

See it on your own floor

The ideas here are how Tablestial already runs. Book a walkthrough and we will set your own restaurant up beside the demo room.

Sign up and we will send you one email a month from Tablestial. Unsubscribe any time with the link in every email. Privacy notice